Are You A Leader Or A Boss?
For ages, there has been a debate between a boss and a leader. Perhaps it is the right time to put a full stop.
Understanding whether you are a leader or a boss requires more than self-reflection. It demands a more detailed look at how you interact with your team and handle various aspects of your designation.
The difference between a boss and a leader lies in your behavior, language, and approach to challenges and successes.
Here’s a closer look at what distinguishes a leader from a boss and some reflective questions to help you evaluate your own leadership style.
The core of leadership is how you engage with your team. Do you support and empower them or sit above them, issuing commands? I found that sitting on top of a hierarchical pyramid was “painful on my bottom.” The more rewarding experience was being a supportive leader rather than an aloof boss.
My friend and mentor, Chris Holmberg, founder of Middle Path Consulting, echoes this idea. He emphasizes that true leaders operate in the middle ground of "WE/US," which fosters an inclusive and supportive environment. By positioning yourself within the team rather than above it, you create a space for collaboration and mutual respect.
Leaders recognize the collective effort behind success. They use words like "OUR vision" and "OUR success" to acknowledge the team's contributions. Conversely, bosses often resort to "MY vision" and "I had great success," highlighting their own importance.
Leaders view challenges as collective obstacles. They ask, "How can I help YOU?" demonstrating their commitment to finding solutions together. On the other hand, bosses tend to say, "These are the challenges YOU will face," shifting the burden solely onto the team.
Similarly, leaders own failures and shield their teams from internal politics. They say, "These are OUR issues. How can WE solve them?" However, bosses resort to blame, leaving team members discouraged with the phrase, "This is why YOU failed."
Leadership is about two-way communication. Leaders genuinely seek feedback on their own contributions by asking, "What feedback do you have for me?" Bosses, on the other hand, focus solely on where the team went wrong with a critical, "YOU went wrong here."
Leaders also share responsibility for results. Instead of focusing on "YOUR numbers," they ask, "How do YOU feel about OUR numbers?" This demonstrates their concern for the team's well-being and encourages open dialogue.
Leadership extends beyond talk. Leaders walk the talk by consistently demonstrating the values they champion. Conversely, bosses often rely solely on pronouncements with little follow-through.
Humble leaders are considerate of the time and work of their team. Rather than making a demand like, "Come see me now," they ask, "Can I come see you?" This polite behavior reflects their understanding of the team's valuable time.
True leadership isn't about a title. It's a role earned through respect and trust. Leaders inspire their teams to naturally bestow the "Leader" title upon them. Bosses, however, tend to grab the title "BOSS" without earning it.
Leadership is about more than just dictating orders. Influential leaders leverage a combination of trust, respect, care, coaching, and shared workload. Bosses, on the other hand, rely on authority and control to manage their teams.
Great leaders inspire their teams to achieve their full potential. They mentor and lead by example, fostering the growth of the next generation. Bosses, however, are threatened by a team's potential and try to maintain control.
The journey from being a boss to a leader is ongoing and requires commitment. By focusing on supportive behaviors, collaborative language, and genuine and supportive actions, you can create a more engaged and motivated team.
So, are you a leader or a boss? Reflect on your behaviors, language, and interactions with your team to gain insight into your leadership style.
If you’re interested in exploring these concepts further and enhancing your leadership skills, I (Mike Plaxton) recommend reading my book “Reflections of a Leader.”
Based on my 50+ years of experience in different leadership roles, “Reflections of a Leader” challenges conventional wisdom and offers a fresh perspective on the complexities of leading people and organizations. By emphasizing real-world application and personal development, readers are better equipped to reach their leadership potential and leave a lasting impression.
Through personal anecdotes, strategic insights, real-life examples, tips, and actionable advice, this book will guide you on a transformative journey of self-discovery and leadership excellence.
Get your copy on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/1917399316/.